Okay, so I’ve been meaning to jot down some thoughts about this whole Drew Brees versus Josh Allen thing. Not like a super deep analysis, you know, just what I’ve seen and how it kinda struck me over time.
I spent years, seriously, years, watching Brees play. It was like clockwork. Every Sunday, you knew what you were getting. Precision, timing, slicing up defenses from the pocket. He wasn’t the biggest guy, didn’t have a rocket arm compared to some, but man, he was smart. He made it look easy, almost surgical. Watching him felt comfortable, predictable in a good way. You just trusted he’d find the open guy.
Then Comes the New Wave
Then you get guys like Josh Allen showing up. And it’s just… different. Completely different energy. It wasn’t comfortable viewing at first, not for me anyway. This dude is huge, runs like a linebacker, and throws the ball like it’s shot out of a cannon. Sometimes it goes exactly where it needs to, sometimes it sails into the stands. It’s wild, unpredictable.
My process here was basically just watching a ton of games, really. Sitting back on the couch, sometimes with friends, sometimes just zoning out after work. I wasn’t pulling up stats or anything, just observing the feel of the game when each of them was playing.
Key Differences I Noticed:
- Pocket vs. Chaos: Brees lived in the pocket. Allen seems to thrive when things break down. He creates chaos.
- Arm Style: Brees was all touch and timing. Allen is raw power, just launching it.
- Physicality: You worried about Brees taking a hit. You worry about the defender when Allen decides to run.
Getting Used to the Change
Honestly, watching Allen more, especially these last couple of seasons, I started to appreciate it. It’s not the same chess match Brees played, it’s more like… well, brute force combined with incredible talent. It took me a while, though. It kind of reminded me of when I had to switch jobs a few years back. I was so used to my old routine, my old way of doing things, felt like I had it all figured out, nice and controlled, like Brees managing the game.

Then I landed in this new place, and everything was faster, louder, more unpredictable. New tools, new expectations, felt like Allen scrambling out of the pocket. Took me a good while to adjust, to see the effectiveness in the new way, even if it felt messy compared to the old ‘precision’ approach I was used to. You learn to appreciate different kinds of effective, I guess. Brees was the master craftsman, Allen is like the force of nature. Both get the job done, just in ways that feel worlds apart when you’re watching them go.
So yeah, that’s my take. Not very technical, just how it registered with me watching them play over the years. It’s interesting seeing that shift happen right before your eyes.